​

If you own Five Guys Triple Net (NNN) real estate, achieving the strongest possible sale outcome starts with positioning the property correctly and exposing it to the broadest appropriate pool of qualified buyers. Highwater Partners combines sophisticated property, lease, tenant, guarantor, and valuation analysis with strategic pricing, national NNN and 1031 exchange buyer outreach, traditional commercial real estate marketing, and Mercedes Shaffer’s direct investor-facing presence through The Commercial Real Estate Deal Room on YouTube. Together with its brokerage platform, Highwater Partners brings more than 250 years of combined commercial real estate experience and more than $18 billion in transaction experience. For a Five Guys property, the franchisee or actual lease entity, remaining lease term, restaurant format, rent economics, and underlying real estate can materially influence buyer underwriting.

A successful Five Guys sale requires more than applying a cap rate to the rent and listing the property online. Five Guys uses a franchise system and accommodates multiple restaurant formats, so an owner should understand the exact tenant and guarantor as well as the physical characteristics of the individual property. Corner, end-cap, inline, freestanding, pedestrian-oriented, and other restaurant settings can present materially different real estate and residual-value considerations.

What Will Buyers Evaluate in My Five Guys NNN Property?

Buyers will evaluate the complete investment rather than relying only on the Five Guys name. A seller should analyze the property through five interconnected layers: Brand → Guarantor & Lease → Income → Location → Underlying Real Estate.

Five Guys has substantial consumer recognition and a broad restaurant footprint, which can help attract initial investor attention. However, brand recognition is not the same as lease credit. Sophisticated NNN buyers will want to determine exactly which entity is responsible for rent, whether another entity guarantees those obligations, and what financial strength stands behind the lease.

This issue is particularly important with franchised restaurant real estate. An individual Five Guys property may involve a franchise entity, multi-unit operator, affiliate, corporate entity, or another structure depending on the specific lease. Sellers should never assume that the national brand itself guarantees the rent unless the lease documentation establishes that obligation.

Buyers will also review remaining firm lease term, scheduled rent increases, renewal options, landlord obligations, assignment language, casualty and condemnation provisions, purchase rights, rights of first refusal, and any unusual termination provisions. These details can affect financing, buyer confidence, pricing, and the size of the potential buyer pool.

For restaurant owners who want a broader framework, the guide to selling QSR Triple Net (NNN) real estate explains how lease quality, tenant credit, property fundamentals, and seller strategy interact in QSR transactions.

How Does the Five Guys Real Estate Format Affect the Sale?

The physical format can materially affect buyer perception because Five Guys restaurants can occupy different types of commercial real estate. A corner or end-cap restaurant may present a different residual-value story from an inline location, freestanding building, or pedestrian-oriented urban property.

Five Guys identifies multiple real estate formats and places importance on attributes such as visibility, frontage, restaurant-ready building conditions, parking where appropriate, signage, and accessibility. For sellers, those characteristics matter because investors are buying both contractual income and the real estate that remains if the tenant eventually leaves.

An end-cap location with strong frontage, convenient access, attractive neighboring tenants, and adequate parking may have meaningful replacement-tenant potential. An inline property may depend more heavily on the quality of the shopping center, co-tenancy, parking field, pedestrian traffic, and surrounding retail environment.

Freestanding properties may offer a different set of advantages, such as greater parcel control, signage, parking, access, and potential adaptability. However, the value of those characteristics depends on the market, site configuration, zoning, building size, traffic patterns, and alternative-use demand.

A seller should therefore avoid presenting a Five Guys property as though the restaurant brand alone explains the investment. The strongest marketing narrative connects the lease income to the quality and flexibility of the underlying real estate.

How Do the Five Guys Franchisee and Guarantor Affect Value?

The actual tenant and guarantor can materially influence buyer demand, financing, and pricing. Before marketing a Five Guys property, the owner should determine precisely which entity signed the lease and what guaranty, if any, supports the rent obligation.

Five Guys operates a significant franchise system, and individual franchise groups can differ in size, capitalization, operating history, and number of restaurants. A buyer may therefore evaluate a substantial multi-unit operator differently from a smaller franchise entity, even though both properties display the same Five Guys brand.

The complete lease package should be reviewed before marketing whenever possible. This includes the original lease, amendments, assignments, guaranties, estoppels, and any other documents that modify the economic relationship between landlord and tenant.

Buyers may examine rent escalations, renewal options, responsibility for taxes and insurance, maintenance, roof and structure, HVAC, parking areas, capital expenditures, assignment rights, casualty provisions, condemnation, purchase options, and termination rights. A lease described as Triple Net should not automatically be assumed to transfer every conceivable property obligation to the tenant.

Remaining firm lease term is another major consideration. Buyers generally distinguish between guaranteed contractual years and future options controlled by the tenant. Owners should understand how remaining lease term can affect the value of an NNN property before a shorter lease changes financing or buyer demand.

How Should a Five Guys NNN Property Be Marketed Nationally?

A Five Guys NNN property should be marketed nationally to buyers whose criteria align with the actual lease, guarantor, income, location, and real estate. The buyer willing to offer the strongest combination of price and transaction terms may be located far outside the property’s local market.

Many Triple Net investors acquire properties across state lines. 1031 exchange investors may search even more broadly because they are often working within specific timing requirements and need replacement properties that fit defined purchase-price, income, tenant, lease-term, financing, and risk parameters.

Highwater Partners combines traditional listing exposure and broker-to-broker marketing with targeted outreach to NNN investors, private investors, family offices, institutional buyers when appropriate, and 1031 exchange capital. Mercedes Shaffer’s investor-facing presence through The Commercial Real Estate Deal Room creates another direct connection with investors interested in Triple Net real estate, passive investment property, tenant and lease risk, valuation, and exchange strategy.

The goal of national marketing is not simply more visibility. It is to increase the opportunity for qualified competition. When multiple credible buyers understand the property and have the ability to close, the seller may gain leverage over price, due-diligence periods, financing contingencies, closing timing, and other transaction terms.

Owners can review why national exposure matters when selling a Triple Net property to understand why buyer reach is an important component of the sale strategy.

When Should I Sell My Five Guys NNN Property?

The best time to sell depends on the individual property’s lease term, guarantor, rent structure, location, condition, financing environment, and the owner’s goals. The decision should ideally be evaluated before an approaching lease event or property issue reduces the seller’s strategic choices.

Remaining firm lease term is often one of the most important timing variables. As a lease gets shorter, financing availability and buyer perception can change. A property approaching an option period may be viewed differently from one with substantial contractual term remaining.

Sellers should also consider upcoming rent increases, lease amendments, renovation or remodel obligations, deferred maintenance, anticipated tenant decisions, changes in the shopping center or trade area, and broader property condition. An owner may benefit from resolving an identifiable issue before marketing if doing so improves buyer confidence or expands the buyer pool.

Five Guys’ mature national footprint also reinforces the importance of property-level differentiation. Buyers will still ask whether the individual location has strong access, visibility, demographics, surrounding retail, parking, trade-area fundamentals, and alternative-use potential.

Evaluating these factors before there is urgency gives the owner greater flexibility to choose between selling immediately, waiting for a contractual event, solving an issue first, or adjusting the positioning strategy.

What Triple Net (NNN) Sellers Often Miss

One issue Five Guys property owners can overlook is the difference between brand recognition and lease credit. The Five Guys name may attract buyers, but investors ultimately need to know which entity is legally responsible for paying rent and whether another entity guarantees that obligation.

Another frequently overlooked factor is the real estate format. Five Guys can operate in end-cap, corner, inline, freestanding, and other commercial settings. Each format has different considerations involving visibility, access, parking, frontage, co-tenancy, building adaptability, and replacement-tenant demand.

Sellers may also assume renewal options are equivalent to guaranteed lease years. They are not necessarily treated the same by buyers or lenders. Firm contractual term generally provides more certainty than future options controlled by the tenant.

Rent also needs context. Buyers may compare contractual rent with the physical real estate, location, potential market rent, and long-term replacement-tenant economics. A strong current income stream is more compelling when investors believe the rent and real estate remain sustainable over time.

Finally, owners may underestimate the importance of national exposure. The eventual buyer could be a private investor, family office, or 1031 exchange purchaser located in another state. Restricting marketing to familiar local buyers can unnecessarily narrow competition.

Bottom Line

Selling a Five Guys Triple Net property successfully requires careful analysis of the actual franchisee or tenant, guarantor, remaining firm lease term, rent economics, restaurant format, location, and underlying real estate. Those characteristics should then be positioned strategically for the appropriate national NNN and 1031 exchange buyer pool.

Highwater Partners helps sellers identify the property’s strengths, anticipate likely buyer objections, establish an informed pricing and positioning strategy, create qualified national exposure, and preserve negotiating leverage throughout the sale process.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is my Five Guys NNN property worth?

A Five Guys property's value depends on the actual tenant and guarantor, remaining firm lease term, rent and escalations, landlord obligations, location, property format, financing environment, and underlying real estate. Brand recognition may support buyer interest, but the property's value should be determined through a property-specific analysis rather than a generic cap rate.

Does the Five Guys franchisee affect what buyers will pay?

Yes. Buyers typically underwrite the legal entity responsible for the lease and any guarantor supporting it. A large multi-unit franchisee, smaller operator, affiliated entity, or other tenant structure can present different risk characteristics. Those differences can influence lender appetite, buyer confidence, marketability, and pricing.

Does an end-cap or corner Five Guys location affect value?

It can. Five Guys identifies corner and end-cap locations as desirable formats while also considering inline and other real estate. Buyers may evaluate visibility, frontage, parking, access, neighboring tenants, signage, pedestrian traffic, building configuration, and replacement-tenant potential when determining the quality of the underlying real estate.

Should I sell before my Five Guys lease gets shorter?

Possibly. As firm lease term declines, financing and buyer demand may change, particularly when the property approaches renewal options or lease expiration. Reviewing the property well in advance allows an owner to compare selling now, waiting for a contractual event, resolving an issue, or negotiating another strategy while multiple choices remain available.

Do 1031 exchange buyers matter when selling a Five Guys property?

Yes. Five Guys NNN real estate may attract 1031 exchange investors seeking contractual income and relatively passive ownership. These buyers frequently search nationally and may operate under strict purchase-price, timing, lease-term, and financing requirements, making broad national marketing relevant to the seller’s strategy.

Why should I use a broker who specializes in NNN property sales?

NNN transactions require specialized analysis of tenant credit, guarantor structure, remaining lease term, rent, financing, valuation, 1031 exchange demand, residual real estate, and national buyer positioning. Owners comparing representation can review the considerations involved in choosing a Triple Net (NNN) broker before bringing a property to market.

Related Triple Net (NNN) Resources

Owners evaluating a possible sale can review when to consider selling a Triple Net (NNN) property to better understand how lease events, property conditions, and market factors may influence timing.

Let’s Connect

Before deciding when or how to sell a Five Guys NNN property, consider obtaining a confidential evaluation of its potential value, tenant and guarantor structure, lease economics, real estate quality, positioning strategy, timing, national marketing plan, and likely buyer pool. Highwater Partners can help determine how sophisticated investors may evaluate the property and develop a strategy designed to broaden qualified exposure while protecting seller leverage.

About Mercedes Shaffer

Mercedes Shaffer is the Founder of Highwater Partners, a commercial real estate advisory firm specializing in Triple Net (NNN) investments, 1031 exchanges, multifamily investment properties, and single-tenant net lease real estate throughout the United States. Together with her brokerage platform, her team brings more than 250 years of combined commercial real estate experience and more than $18 billion in transaction experience.

Mercedes advises private investors, family offices, developers, and institutional investors on the acquisition, disposition, valuation, and exchange of investment real estate. Her expertise includes tenant credit analysis, lease structure, cap rates and valuation, 1031 exchange strategy, market and location fundamentals, and the evaluation of risk in Triple Net investments.

In addition to her advisory work, Mercedes is also the creator and host of the Commercial Real Estate Deal Room, an educational platform focused on helping investors understand Triple Net real estate, 1031 exchanges, lease and tenant risk, valuation, and the transition from management-intensive properties into more passive real estate investments.

Mercedes is known for an analytical approach that goes “beyond the cap rate” and the glossy brochure. Rather than evaluating an investment solely by its advertised yield or the name on the building, she examines the tenant, lease, underlying real estate, market fundamentals, exit strategy, and the investor’s broader objectives.

Her philosophy is straightforward: there is no universally “best” Triple Net property—only an investment whose combination of real estate, income, risk, and long-term strategy may or may not be appropriate for a particular investor. That perspective guides her work across acquisitions, dispositions, 1031 exchanges, and long-term investment strategy.