top of page

Dutch Bros NNN Property for Sale in Santa Maria, California | $2,670,000 | 5.15% Cap Rate

By Mercedes Shaffer | Commercial Real Estate Broker & NNN Investment Specialist


A Dutch Bros Coffee investment property at 1760 North Broadway in Santa Maria, California, is being offered for $2,670,000 at a 5.15% cap rate, generating $137,500 in annual net operating income. The property features a modern dual-drive-through coffee location constructed in 2020, with more than 10 years remaining on a corporate-guaranteed absolute NNN lease.

The investment combines a growing national beverage brand, scheduled rental increases, and a prominent location along one of Santa Maria's established commercial corridors. Unlike a ground lease investment, this offering includes fee-simple ownership of both the land and building.


However, investors should look beyond the recognizable brand and relatively passive lease structure. The property's valuation depends on the strength of the actual lease guarantor, the store's operating performance, and the long-term value of the underlying real estate.

On the Commercial Real Estate Deal Room, I go beyond the cap rate and the glossy brochure to evaluate the tenant, the lease, the underlying real estate, and the risk.


Property Overview

  • Tenant: Dutch Bros Coffee

  • Address: 1760 North Broadway, Santa Maria, California 93454

  • Asking Price: $2,670,000

  • Cap Rate: 5.15%

  • Annual NOI: $137,500

  • Building Size: 862 square feet

  • Land Area: 0.92 acres

  • Year Built: 2020

  • Ownership: Fee Simple — Land and Building

  • Lease: Corporate-Guaranteed Absolute NNN

  • Remaining Term: More than 10 years

  • Rent Increases: 10% every five years

  • Renewal Options: Three five-year options

  • Parking: 10 spaces

  • Zoning: C2 — General Commercial

  • Frontage: 255 feet on North Broadway

About Dutch Bros: Brand Growth and Corporate Credit

Dutch Bros is a publicly traded beverage retailer specializing in drive-through coffee, energy drinks, teas, and other customized beverages. Its operating model emphasizes convenience, speed, and customer engagement, with relatively small buildings designed around high-volume drive-through service.

The company's expansion has attracted considerable attention from both consumers and commercial real estate investors. Its recognizable branding and drive-through-focused format may support demand in markets where customers prioritize convenient beverage purchases.

However, rapid expansion does not automatically establish investment-grade credit. Investors should distinguish the company's national growth story from the financial strength of the specific entity responsible for the Santa Maria lease.

The offering describes the lease as corporate guaranteed, which is an attractive feature. However, it does not identify the exact legal tenant or guarantor. I would want to review the executed lease and guaranty agreement to determine whether the obligations are supported by Dutch Bros Inc., an operating subsidiary, or another affiliated entity.

The distinction matters because the enforceable guaranty determines which company's financial resources support the rental payments. A publicly traded brand does not automatically mean that every lease is guaranteed by its publicly traded parent.

The offering also does not disclose store-level sales or profitability. These figures would help establish whether the location generates sufficient operating income to support its rent and remain strategically important to Dutch Bros.

Location and Real Estate Analysis

The property is located along North Broadway in Santa Maria, within Santa Barbara County on California's Central Coast. Santa Maria serves as a regional commercial and employment center, with retail activity supported by residential neighborhoods, agriculture, tourism, and surrounding communities.

The offering emphasizes the property's position within a dense retail corridor near hospitality businesses and regional transportation routes. This concentration of commercial activity may support demand for convenient food and beverage purchases.

North Broadway provides an established commercial setting, while the property's approximately 255 feet of frontage may contribute to visibility and customer awareness. However, investors should evaluate actual driveway access, traffic movements, and the building's orientation rather than relying exclusively on frontage measurements.

The offering also references proximity to U.S. Highway 101. This regional transportation connection may support customer activity, but freeway traffic should not be confused with vehicles directly passing the property's entrance.

For a drive-through coffee business, convenient access is particularly important. Customers frequently make quick purchases during commuting hours, and even a well-located store may underperform if entry and exit are difficult.

The property occupies approximately 0.92 acres and contains an 862-square-foot building. The relatively small building footprint allows much of the site to accommodate vehicle circulation, parking, and drive-through operations.

The offering identifies 10 parking spaces and a dual-drive-through configuration. The dual-lane format may support higher customer throughput, but investors should evaluate stacking capacity, traffic flow, and potential congestion during peak periods.

The property's C2 General Commercial zoning may provide flexibility for alternative commercial uses. However, permitted uses, parking requirements, and redevelopment standards should be verified through the City of Santa Maria.

Dual Drive-Through Design and Store Performance

The property's dual-drive-through configuration is an important feature because Dutch Bros relies heavily on vehicle-based transactions. A well-designed drive-through can help the operator serve customers efficiently during periods of high demand.

However, the existence of two drive-through lanes does not establish strong sales performance. Investors should evaluate the number of vehicles the site can accommodate, the speed of service, and whether customer queues interfere with parking or access.

The offering describes the building as Dutch Bros' latest prototype. Modern store designs may incorporate operational improvements, but investors should determine whether those improvements translate into better performance at this location.

The reported annual NOI of $137,500 is the most important financial figure available to the investor. However, the offering does not disclose the tenant's annual sales, store-level EBITDA, or rent coverage.

For illustration, if the store generated $2 million in annual sales, $137,500 in rent would represent approximately 6.9% of revenue. At $3 million in sales, the ratio would decline to approximately 4.6%.

These are hypothetical scenarios, not verified sales figures for the Santa Maria location. They illustrate why store-level economics matter when evaluating a single-tenant retail investment.

I would want to review historical sales trends and determine whether the location has maintained consistent performance since its 2020 construction. The tenant's willingness to remain at the property will ultimately depend on the location's profitability and strategic importance.

Understanding the Absolute NNN Lease

The offering describes the property as a corporate-guaranteed absolute NNN investment with zero landlord responsibilities. This structure may appeal to investors seeking predictable income without the management requirements associated with multi-tenant commercial properties.

Under an absolute NNN lease, the tenant generally assumes responsibility for property taxes, insurance, maintenance, and major capital expenditures. However, the executed lease determines the actual allocation of obligations.

I would want to verify responsibility for roof repairs, structural maintenance, HVAC replacement, parking areas, and other capital expenditures. The offering's statement of zero landlord responsibilities is encouraging, but it should be confirmed through the contractual documents.

The property is offered as fee-simple ownership of both land and building. This differs from a leased-fee ground lease, where the investor's rights to the improvements depend on the ground lease provisions.

Fee-simple ownership may provide additional flexibility after the tenant's lease expires. However, the investor's ability to use or redevelop the property remains subject to zoning, easements, and other applicable restrictions.

The lease reportedly has more than 10 years remaining, providing a meaningful period of contractual income. However, the offering does not disclose the exact expiration date, and investors should confirm it before underwriting the property.

Scheduled Rent Increases and Long-Term Income

The lease includes 10% rental increases every five years during the initial term and at the beginning of each renewal option. This provides a contractual mechanism for income growth without requiring the landlord to renegotiate rent during the primary lease term.

Based on the reported $137,500 annual NOI, a 10% increase would raise annual income to approximately $151,250, assuming NOI increases proportionately. At the original purchase price, this would increase the investor's yield on cost from approximately 5.15% to 5.66%.

A second 10% increase would raise annual income to approximately $166,375, producing a yield on cost of approximately 6.23%.

These calculations are illustrative. The actual timing of rent increases depends on the lease commencement date and the contractual rent schedule.

The 10% increases every five years represent approximately 1.92% compounded annual growth. This provides some inflation protection, although it may not fully offset periods of higher inflation.

The lease also includes three five-year renewal options. These may extend the tenant's occupancy substantially, but they are controlled by the tenant under the terms of the lease.

Investors should not treat optional periods as guaranteed income. The tenant's decision to renew will depend on store performance, market conditions, and corporate strategy.

Understanding the 5.15% Cap Rate

At the $2,670,000 asking price, the reported $137,500 annual NOI produces a cap rate of approximately 5.15%. This represents the property's initial unleveraged income yield before financing costs and acquisition expenses.

The asking price represents approximately 19.4 times annual NOI. Investors are therefore paying a substantial income multiple for the corporate-guaranteed lease, newer construction, scheduled rent growth, and Santa Maria location.

The 5.15% cap rate is higher than certain lower-yielding ground lease investments, but it still represents a relatively modest initial return. Investors should determine whether the tenant credit and real estate fundamentals justify that valuation.

Cap rate sensitivity illustrates the potential effect of changing investor return requirements. If the property's $137,500 NOI were valued at a 6.00% cap rate, the indicated value would decline to approximately $2,291,667.

At a 6.50% cap rate, the indicated value would be approximately $2,115,385. Conversely, at a 4.75% cap rate, the indicated value would be approximately $2,894,737.

These calculations assume the same NOI and are illustrative rather than forecasts. Future value will depend on the rent in effect at resale, remaining lease term, tenant credit, and prevailing market conditions.

Scheduled rental increases may help offset some valuation risk over time. However, investors should model future NOI and exit cap rates together rather than assuming that rent growth guarantees appreciation.

Financing is another important consideration. If borrowing costs approach or exceed the property's 5.15% initial yield, leverage may reduce cash-on-cash returns.

I would want to model the property's cash-on-cash return under multiple financing scenarios, including changes in interest rates and exit cap rates. The initial yield may be appropriate for certain investors, but the margin for error remains relatively limited.

Underlying Real Estate Value and Re-Tenanting Potential

The property occupies approximately 0.92 acres along an established Santa Maria commercial corridor. Its substantial frontage, dual-drive-through configuration, and general commercial zoning may support long-term real estate demand.

At the $2,670,000 asking price, the implied purchase price is approximately $67 per square foot of land. This calculation allocates the entire investment price to the land area and does not represent an independent appraisal of vacant land value.

Investors should compare the asking price with recent commercial land transactions and retail property sales in Santa Maria and surrounding Central Coast markets. The relevant question is whether the underlying real estate provides sufficient residual value if Dutch Bros eventually vacates.

The property's 862-square-foot building is purpose-built for a drive-through beverage operation. This may appeal to another coffee or quick-service restaurant operator, but alternative uses could require modifications to the building or site circulation.

The relatively large parcel compared with the building footprint may provide flexibility for certain alternative uses. However, zoning restrictions, parking requirements, and easements may limit redevelopment options.

The property's location along North Broadway is encouraging, but investors should not assume that another operator will pay the same rent as Dutch Bros. Achievable market rent and re-tenanting costs should be evaluated independently.

Investment Risks and Considerations

Corporate Guaranty: The offering describes a corporate-guaranteed lease but does not identify the exact guarantor. Investors should verify the legal entity responsible for the obligations and review its financial strength.

Store-Level Performance: The offering does not provide sales or profitability figures. Investors should determine whether the location can comfortably support the $137,500 annual rent.

Low Initial Yield: The 5.15% cap rate provides a relatively modest initial return. Changes in interest rates or investor return requirements may materially affect resale value.

Lease Terms: The offering states that more than 10 years remain, but the exact expiration date is not disclosed. Investors should verify the rent schedule, renewal options, and contractual obligations.

Drive-Through Access: The property's value depends partly on convenient vehicle circulation. Investors should evaluate driveway access, stacking capacity, and potential traffic conflicts.

Alternative Use Risk: The building is purpose-built for a drive-through beverage operator. Investors should evaluate the cost of converting the property if Dutch Bros eventually vacates.

Is This Dutch Bros NNN Property a Good Investment?

My assessment is that this property offers several attractive characteristics, including newer construction, a corporate-guaranteed absolute NNN lease, scheduled rental increases, and a prominent location along North Broadway in Santa Maria.

The fee-simple ownership structure may also appeal to investors seeking long-term control of the underlying land and building. The property's relatively large parcel and dual-drive-through configuration may provide additional utility.

However, the 5.15% cap rate leaves relatively little margin for underwriting errors. Investors are paying a premium for the tenant's growth potential, lease structure, and location.

The first issue I would investigate is the credit supporting the lease. I would want to confirm the exact legal tenant and guarantor before assigning a corporate credit premium.

The second issue is store-level economics. The offering does not disclose sales or profitability, making it difficult to determine whether the tenant can comfortably support its rental obligations.

The third issue is underlying real estate value. The property's location and land area may provide residual value, but the asking price should be evaluated against comparable transactions.

For a 1031 exchange investor prioritizing passive ownership, contractual rent growth, and fee-simple real estate, this Dutch Bros property may warrant consideration. However, investors seeking a higher initial yield or independently verified store-level performance may find the pricing less compelling.

Ultimately, the investment's attractiveness depends on whether the tenant credit, lease structure, store performance, and underlying real estate justify the $2.67 million asking price.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this Dutch Bros property an absolute NNN investment?

Yes, the offering describes an absolute NNN lease with zero landlord responsibilities. Buyers should verify the expense allocation in the executed lease.

How much income does this Dutch Bros property generate?

The offering reports $137,500 in annual NOI, representing a 5.15% cap rate at the $2,670,000 asking price.

How long is the Dutch Bros lease?

More than 10 years remain, with three five-year renewal options. The exact expiration date should be verified.

Is the Dutch Bros lease corporate guaranteed?

The offering describes a corporate guaranty but does not identify the exact guarantor. Buyers should review the executed guaranty documents.

Related NNN Investment Resources

How Are Triple Net Properties Valued?

How Does Remaining Lease Term Affect NNN Property Value?

What Is My NNN Property Worth?

How to Choose the Best NNN Broker

Discuss NNN Investment Opportunities

Whether you're evaluating a Dutch Bros investment, selling an existing NNN property, or considering a 1031 exchange, understanding the tenant's financial strength, lease structure, and underlying real estate is essential. At Highwater Partners, I help investors and property owners evaluate commercial real estate opportunities based on tenant credit, lease terms, market fundamentals, and long-term investment objectives.

About Mercedes Shaffer

Mercedes Shaffer is a commercial real estate broker specializing in Triple Net (NNN) real estate, multifamily investment properties, and 1031 exchanges. With over 20 years of real estate experience, Mercedes helps property owners and investors buy, sell, value, and strategically reposition income-producing real estate. Her expertise encompasses investment property valuation, market fundamentals, lease structures, tenant credit analysis, and the factors that influence long-term investment performance.

Together, Mercedes and her team at Highwater Partners bring more than 250 years of combined commercial real estate experience and over $18 billion in transaction experience. Mercedes is also the host of The Commercial Real Estate Deal Room, a YouTube channel focused on helping investors understand NNN properties, 1031 exchanges, commercial real estate valuation, and investment risk. Her approach emphasizes evaluating the tenant, lease, underlying real estate, and financial considerations that ultimately influence investment performance.

ChatGPT Image Sep 22, 2026, 02_43_46 PM_edited.jpg

CONTACT US

Reach out if you have questions or would like to schedule a confidential consultation.

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page